So far, I'd have to say the Polynesian. We did, however, take advantadge of great moonlit strolls along the streets of French Quarter, but there's just something about the Poly. The lit tiki torches at night, listening to the water ripple in on the beach as you lay in the hammock, watching the fireworks from Sunset Point. Pretty awesome! We're going to try Caribbean Beach in May by ourselves, so I'll let you know the "romantic" factor of that resort when we return.