Everyone has there own favorite for 1 reason or another. Personally we like the AERAERA. The best thing I can say is to request the rotation that best fits what youre looking for, as early as you can. Usually the dining room seating etc isnt made until a few weeks before a cruise so the earlier the better. When you call and ask, ask what nights formal and semi formal are and ask for the rotation that fits is the closest. You may get 1 but not the other depending on the nights. For example, we just got off of the Fantasy eastern,and had AERAERA. Formal was the first Enchanted and Semi Formal was the last night in AP.