...wow, I feel so much better! They had a 'special' for a 3-day (with 3 days free) for $219.47 pp. When I had gone to the Disney Store on Sunday, THEIR 4-day was $273.00!! I have to buy 4 tix, so that is quite a savings.....
Are you sure you are comparing the same tickets? Disney's price for a 4-day should be 225.78 with tax, according to Mousesavers. If you were looking at Park Hoppers, however, the price goes up by about $48 per ticket, which would be $273. Undercover Tourist is legit and offers some savings, but I wouldn't expect it to be that significant. You might check to see if the UT tickets are not hoppers and the Disney Store tickets were.
Isn't that deal only good for certain days in Jan and Feb?
...you could be right about that...however, the CM brought out her book with the upc codes and there wasn't a page for "non-park-hopping" passes....