Some places offer a discount if you dont get what you register for. A girl I know put a huge tv on it, knowing she most likely wouldnt get it and they bought it after ward with a 15 % discount I think.
Exactly.
The process of registering is a weird one. I didn't want to do it at all, I had been an avowed registry hater, but then everyone kept bugging me about it. So I figured that instead of telling people what I wanted (which was simply their presence, but no one believed me) I would just do a registry.
Let me tell you, guys LOVE that scanner gun. I would let hubby play with it at the store, then later get online when we were on home and would find SO many things he'd scanned literally behind my back (thankfully all those scans of my butt didn't make it onto the list, LOL). So unless they are avowed gamers, I personally would just assume that hubby either got bored at the store, or they put it on there to buy themselves later with the discount.
Nowadays I try to go off of registries, and I have no problem buying giftcards if I see nothing I want to give or can afford. I liked getting the giftcards, b/c you could pool them to buy things from the registry.
That said, two of the most remembered gifts we got were bright green candlesticks and a soup tureen in the shape of a big thing of cauliflower (went along with a soup recipe book). And we remember them b/c, it turns out, that we like them.
I would never have picked out that soup thing on my own, but it cracks me up (in a good way) and I can't wait to really use it (with just the three of us, I don't normally make enough soup to fill a tureen), and I love the color of the candlesticks.
However, with a baby registry, unless there are some drastic mistakes on there (my friend had NO simple onesies on her baby registry, for instance, it was all fussy stuff), just go with the registry or a giftcard. Don't get fancy. My friend (same with the problem registry) invited some of HER friends to my shower b/c she thought there were too few people (sigh). They barely knew me. They got very large and cheap bottles that were almost for sure from the dollar store. They got me some weird formula-mixing thing. They got me some other weird things. My friend got nursery rhyme books but obviously didn't look in them, b/c they were THE most racist, awful nursery rhymes, and we had to throw them away (there was one rhyme about a slave woman having to sell her children????). I was, and am, an avowed mama milk advocate along with being a delayed-solids person, and the things the friends bought me literally went in the trash. So don't do things like that.
About the problem registry...turns out this friend didn't actually choose much of anything. She went to the sites or the stores, found the button that said something like "registry for baby girl", and clicked that. If there were things she specifically wanted, and if choosing that popped up something like "people that chose that also chose this", she would then choose this. She put NO thought into her registries...she had 4, and there were multiples of the same items on both sites...she's an avowed formula user, and she had something like 4 DIFFERENT, and incomplete, bottle sets on her various registries, LOL. I bought from her registry, and NO ONE ELSE did, and when she opened my stuff (disney themed outfits and some Robeez that weren't on her registry but she'd registered for the cheaper Target ones so I figured that was an OK upgrade), she didn't recognize the things she'd registered for, b/c she had barely chosen anything at all.
Anyway, that's just some anecdotes about why registries can be weird. Hope it helps.