So we completed our stay at the Swan on Sunday 1/31. This was the first time we've stayed at Swolphin. Those of you that know me from the DISboards I Love CC thread probably know that I have over a million Marriott points and had toyed with staying at Swolphin for a long time... So FWIW, here's an assessment of the Swan from a first-timer!
The Swan was very nice. The location cannot be beat! We used 144,000 Bonvoy Points to stay for 5 nights (w/ 5th night free benefit)- and this presented an amazing value for us. We have stayed at BC, YC, and YC on our 3 past trips (we go in January each year) and we found this location to offer similar accommodations and benefits. It was clear that this was not a Disney resort, but with each day that passed, that became less of an issue for me. I also think during non-COVID times we would have spent more time in the BW area exploring and eating and that would've given me more of that "Disney bubble" feeling.
We typically do a split stay on these trips and transfer to the MK area for the 2nd portion of our stay. However, this year, we shortened our trip by a few days and remained in one place (mostly due to a number of COVID related factors). With the elimination of DME, I really think Swolphin will remain a great option for us moving forward. I believe we'll resume our split stays, but have Swan replace Yacht Club. It troubles me to type that because we LOOOOOVE the Yacht Club, seriously it is my fave Disney resort of the 10+ resorts we've experienced. But with our points stash, it's hard to pass up $40 a night (resort fee) vs. the full cost of YC.
We never gave the Swan buses a chance. I have no interest in ending up at the TTC so we walked to BW on both of our MK days. We walk fairly fast, I found it to take about 5 minutes. And since that worked so well, we also walked over on our AK day. Sorry that I can't provide any good DPs of the Swan bus service, BUT I can tell you that there was NOBODY in sight who would've policed us using the BW buses so that option should continue to work in the future unless they change something significantly.
On our last day we took a walk all around the Swolphin grounds and they are really beautiful. We saw the pools, played a game of giant chess, and just enjoyed the ambiance.
So for me, if I'd rate YC as a 9/10 for us, I'd say Swan is more like a 7/10... but the value for us can't be beat, and I'd imagine I'll be back here. I will be closely monitoring the 30 min. early entry situation though... if Swolphin does not have that benefit, or if FP comes back and Official Disney resorts receive some benefit there, we would turn our eyes back to YC in a heartbeat.