Whenever we go to Florida we always rent a villa and have used the same website each time. The villas that are on that site are verified by the site owners to confirm that the villa owners are who they say they are so you can feel confident that all is well and we have only had good trips so far.
Whenever we go we draw up a short list of what we want from our villa and it goes something like this.
1. South fencing pool and jacuzzi with either lake or conservation view. (we personally dont like the ones that are fenced as it seems too claustraphobic)
2. Large deck area and lanai so there is shade for the ones that want shade
3. PC or wireless connection for a laptop
4. Free local international phone calls
5. Games room
We then put an enquiry out for all the villas that have the amount of rooms we want and the ones that can meet our check list and have the dates we want get back to us. Saves on a whole lot of searching and we get what we want.
I cannot post links yet so if you want the site then drop me a PM I will forward you the details.
Pegasus