It has always been my habit - and others I have observed - to tip the valet who parks my car and then also tip the one who retrieves it. There has been great discussion on the boards as to what is proper. Some posters stated the WDW valets all pool their tips and that you ONLY tip the guy who retrieves the vehicle. We stayed at BWV this trip and valet parking is the only way to go when staying there and I wanted to know what their policy really was. So I asked. There were two CM's at the booth - guy & gal. I asked the young lady what the normal practice was and that I'd heard the valets pool their tips so tipping the retriever was most commonly done. She started giving a very polite but indirect answer that tipping was at my discretion, not mandatory but appriciated,yada,yada,yada..... but only left me just as bewildered. The other CM was paying attention and just as I was about to leave he politely informed me that the valets definitely DO NOT pool their tips and then added " I hope that helps answer your question" which it did 100 %. I tipped each valet and had excellent service.