I feel like I'm always saying this, but it's true. It really depends on what you look for in a dining experience, as to whether the Chef's Table will be worth it for you or not. If you are interested in food preparation, rather than candlelight and harps, then this is the table for you. If you like talking to the chef and the sous chef and the cooks, while you are dining or in between courses, then you will love this experience. If you'd rather have a quiet dinner, without making talk and asking questions, or without watching lobsters quiver on the counter across from your table, as they are twisted in half while you eat dinner, then you would probably be happier in the main dining room. If the sight of a raw duck liver the size of a football upsets you, then you wouldn't find this table worth the money.
We personally love the Chef's Table, and eat there every time we go to WDW, but we aren't bothered by the quivering lobsters or the huge, raw duck livers. And we really enjoy talking to the chef and the cooks, asking them questions about their job, or about the foods they are preparing. My husband loves to cook, so this is a fantastic experience for him every time we go there.
I will admit to being a bit bothered by the shaking lobsters - not enough to stop me from eating them, of course
but it did cause me to avert my eyes. But, like I said, we love the Chef's Table. We've only ever eaten here, not in the main dining room. Our wedding reception was in the private room, which is the closest we've ever come to that main dining room atmosphere. I enjoyed it, but it's worth the sacrifice of the romantic atmosphere, and the extra money, to see the glow in my husband's eyes as he watches the cooks go to work on that big old foie gras. This table is definitely our cup of tea, but that's not to say that it's everyone's idea of a romantic night out.
Cheers!
Heather W