Just went to insuremytrip - that was so very helpful as you can read hundreds of reviews, including of people who had various claims - which is when the insurance really shows its colors I guess!
The most important thing: read the fine print!
I was surprised for example, that Allianz did not have "Hurricane Warning coverage" (I had called them directly initially).
We decided on TravelInsured-WorldwideTripProtector.
What was most important to me:
Insurance handles claims well. Hurricane coverage. Great Med Evac coverage, including to "hospital of choice".