There has been much discussion about fundraising and going door to door, and whether or not it is work, appropriate or just an annoyance to others by people who are trying to get others to fund their children's activities.
1. Saying that sales are going door to door is not "real work" is totally inaccurate. It is hard and often thankless work for adults much less children who at times get door slammed in their faces and even yelled at (thankfully that is rare) If sales is not "real work" what is? Only Doctors (I'll accept that), lawyers who make tons of money writing and talking to win cases but only of you pay more than the opponent, bankers and wall street executives whose job it is to gamble the money that belongs to people who labor for it so they can get a percentage, and maybe teachers (but there are heated debates over whether a job that teaches future generations has much value, Really?)
2. While sports, the arts, (music, dance, theater) and other activities all have educational value and help to make well rounded people, scouts is completely different.
Scouts have to do service projects for the community in order earn their advancements. They collect food for the local food pantry, clean up trash that people throw carelessly about town, plant trees and flowers in local parks, help the elderly and bake and deliver goods to local police, fire and first aid stations just to name a few. The older scouts do projects like build benches for local parks, renovate playgrounds, help repair things for people in need of help, clean up outside storm damage, clean and repair people's homes from damage like hurricane Sandy and are trained in first aid, cpr and swimming in order to help injured people. They learn how to use tools, build and implement medical attention at the scouts in order to offer these free services. Scouts are training with the idea that when people help each other everything is better. It seems that our recent generations of "me first" and I am only worrying about myself hasn't turned out so great. We have produced a society in which a lucky few make tons of money off of the majority who toil and labor while living in poverty to make money for someone else's benefit.
3. The fundraising dollars goes towards differing the cost of pack events, and a portion also goes into the scouts personal account as well in order to cover expenses for scouting projects and activities. They even open a college fund for boys who sell enough to qualify.
With all of this going on I fail to see how this is just a fun after school activity.
1. Saying that sales are going door to door is not "real work" is totally inaccurate. It is hard and often thankless work for adults much less children who at times get door slammed in their faces and even yelled at (thankfully that is rare) If sales is not "real work" what is? Only Doctors (I'll accept that), lawyers who make tons of money writing and talking to win cases but only of you pay more than the opponent, bankers and wall street executives whose job it is to gamble the money that belongs to people who labor for it so they can get a percentage, and maybe teachers (but there are heated debates over whether a job that teaches future generations has much value, Really?)
2. While sports, the arts, (music, dance, theater) and other activities all have educational value and help to make well rounded people, scouts is completely different.
Scouts have to do service projects for the community in order earn their advancements. They collect food for the local food pantry, clean up trash that people throw carelessly about town, plant trees and flowers in local parks, help the elderly and bake and deliver goods to local police, fire and first aid stations just to name a few. The older scouts do projects like build benches for local parks, renovate playgrounds, help repair things for people in need of help, clean up outside storm damage, clean and repair people's homes from damage like hurricane Sandy and are trained in first aid, cpr and swimming in order to help injured people. They learn how to use tools, build and implement medical attention at the scouts in order to offer these free services. Scouts are training with the idea that when people help each other everything is better. It seems that our recent generations of "me first" and I am only worrying about myself hasn't turned out so great. We have produced a society in which a lucky few make tons of money off of the majority who toil and labor while living in poverty to make money for someone else's benefit.
3. The fundraising dollars goes towards differing the cost of pack events, and a portion also goes into the scouts personal account as well in order to cover expenses for scouting projects and activities. They even open a college fund for boys who sell enough to qualify.
With all of this going on I fail to see how this is just a fun after school activity.