I've never been to either but I subscribed to this thread BECAUSE, I am pondering the same thing. We stayed at POR last time. This time July 2014 I was set on CSR but then I hear about Swan/Dolphin and I love Westin Hotels & the location is amazing! The disney theme at the hotel means little to nothing to me. The luxury does. I can't afford WL or CR, but I could Swan/dolphin. So why am I still considering CSR?? I like the DDP & I like the idea of room key, park tix, WP tickets, and charging all on one key or band. I'm a bit unorganized so the thought of all that @ "stuff" together is something that's valuable to me.