I think Chef Mickey's would be fun. Do you have a daughter? Cinderella's Royal Table or the Princess meal in Norway would be nice for her.
The Crystal palace seems to be a favorite among alot of people. I have never gone because it is always way too crowded for my taste.
Liberty Tavern Inn in the Magic Kingdom is a character dinner that is very fun. Note that it is only the dinner that has the characters.
I also like Le Cellier,50's Prime Time,Tusker House(counter service),Columbia House(counter service) and Main Street Bakery(counter service-some people feel it is better to pay out of pocket here).
In Downtown Disney there is the Earl of Sandwich(counter).The sandwiches here are very filling so it is highly unlikely that the hungries will come back after one of these.
If you are going to CRT(Cinderella's Royal Table)you need to make your reservations at the 90 day mark. It goes fast. Also,if you can't get into the breakfast try for lunch(it just started having characters). Dinner does not have characters.
In fact it probably will be best to make all your PS/ADRs at the 90 day mark. If you change your mind you can always cancel.
Before I forget, Cinderella's has a deposit that is required. Its 10.00 for adults and 5 for children(somebody will correct me if I am wrong).