We are staying at All-Star Movies right now. I requested a first floor room in the Mighty Duck section and we got it. Both my room and my friend's connecting room have working fridges.
We've stayed previously at AoA LM room and Cars Suite. Loved the resort, HATED the walk from LM to the main building/buses.
We've also stayed at Pop Century in the 50's section.
I noticed that the All-Star resorts are definitely showing their age more than AoA (obviously) and Pop Century.
I was also surprised at how much smaller each of the All-Star resorts are compared to AoA and Pop. This is not a bad thing though, IMO.
At the end of the day, I was looking for a room that would be convenient and that is exactly what we have. Our rooms are literally just outside the Mighty Duck pool area and it is a mere two minute walk to the main building and buses (we walk to All-Star Music). It's like having a room in the preferred section without paying for it. Even if we did have to walk to the main building and buses at All-Star Movies, it would still be much shorter than the walk I had to my rooms at AoA and Pop.
Convenience being my main criteria, I personally would choose this resort in this section again over any of the other values.