Rarity is in the eye of the beholder. Unlike furniture, players are fickle when it comes to pins. The pin is still rare, but if you watch the trade "market", it fluctuates. Mostly it doesn't seem very rare, but I have seen a few months where it's been the "in" pin that everybody is looking for, and suddenly it is worth inferno all on its own. In the last couple weeks it seems to be in demand again for some reason. I've been asked several times if I'm trading mine. Yet for more than three months prior, nobody I knew even wanted it. When it comes to pins, especially this one, it all depends on the demand at the time.