Can I ask if you think it is really worth going the DVC route? Is it that much better than Pop? Has anyone stayed in both Pop and AKV?
This comes down to how you feel about accommodation. The DVC is considered deluxe and Pop is more Value.
It just depends on how much you value the additional 'intangible' items offered at the duluxe vs value and whether you will be at the resort to enjoy them.
In my experience, renting DVC can end up costing somewhere about the moderate resort price bracket. It allows you to experience a deluxe resort at a more affordable price.
I have heard it is difficult to book the cheaper DVC options and that we need to do it so early. Not sure I will be that organised, to be honest! And then we'd be locked in wouldn't we (ie no flexiibility)?
I'm not sure what you mean about no flexibility? If you mean that you're locking your travel dates in, this again comes down to how likely you are to shift your dates.
DVC availability will depend on whether any of the 'owners' are willing to rent their points out. And then it also depends on whether the room category you want is available at the time you want to travel. DVC room bookings open 11 months out from their travel dates for owners of that particular home resort. If you are seeking a room in a specific resort, you may want to get in early so that you lock in the availability and the room of your choice.
Pop seems a lot simpler process to book (ie just do it all directly through Disney, in combination with park tickets) and I have heard that the transportation service is good.
Have you priced out Disney tickets from Disney compared to somewhere like
Undercover Tourist? The convenience of having everything done through the one booking is great and all that but it comes down to whether the savings in dollars for the family is worth de-bundling and buying them separately.
There are a number of ANZAC Dis-sers who have booked DVC through Davids or through owners directlly and they can provide their viewpoint as to whether it is easier or not.
I am lucky enough to know an owner so I have always booked via the owner rather than Davids. It does help that the owner and I trust each other so there are no issues with the transaction. I can honestly say that there is a little bit more paperwork and emails going back and forth; but for the price that I pay for staying at a DVC deluxe resort, it is well worth it. And because I normally buy tix for more than 7 days for WDW, the extra dollars that I save from buying tix through
UT is also worth it for me.
But then I worry that, with January packages not opening until end of July, it means we would already be into the 180 ADR window before we have even booked our room package - so would we miss out on some ADR's? (Do they have to be booked exactly 180 days out, or could we wait until a bit closer?)
Zanzibar has already pointed out that you can lock in your ADRs without having to have any accommodation booked in. Disney does not mandate that you need to have accommodation booked when you book your dining because this allows off-site guests to also book in dining. They open the booking window 180 days out for everyone. Again, it's a supply/demand equation. If you have your heart set on eating at a particular restaurant and want to book in at the dining times of your choice, I would highly recommend that you ring in bang on the 180 day mark. A lot of the highly regarded places do book out. There are cancellations that do occur; especially when you get close to the 45 day mark (when Disney bookings can be cancelled without penalty) and it will come down to how you feel about waiting to see if anything opens up. There are no guarantees that the restaurant you want at the time you want to eat will open up afterwards.
Also, following on from LivingforDisney's comment about room discounts in January, I have looked into it and seen that this is correct - but they usually aren't released until sometime in October. Isn't that cutting it a bit fine? I don't think we could wait that late before booking (surely we'd miss ADR's by then?
Depending on how you feel, you may want to book a room at full rack rate and wait for the discounts to come out. When they do, you will want to call Disney ASAP to cancel the original booking and/or change it for the discount rate. Again, discounts are dependent on Disney offering them and Disney will determine how many rooms they will release at the discounted rate. If you call in early, your chances of securing the discount is greater than if you wait (like everything else at WDW! LOL).
And we'd have to be ready to go for FP+ too)
I think the rule still stands. You will need to have an on-site room booking in order to access FP+ 2 months in advance.
So many questions...
(Oh, and Wanderlust, I don't think we'd want to do a split stay during WDW time, as we are already moving across to Universal for 3 days as well, plus of course Denver, NYC and Washington - it'd be nice to put down roots somewhere for 11 nights without having to move again after a short time. If we were staying put in WDW we'd probably do it - we did it at DL last year, when we stayed at Hojos for 10 nights, then went to GCH for 4 nights, and that was fantastic! So it's not that we're against the idea of split stay, but I feel we are already sort of doing it between WDW and Universal
)
Ask away!
There are so many great resorts at WDW that a split stay may be worth it so that you can experience as many of them in the one trip. It's totally up to you, of course, and I can understand the wanting to stay in the one spot thing.