We went in Feb'09 and while we were at the table, my daughter's tooth fell out! The waitress saw it and she told us she'd be back. She got all of us our drinks then proceeded to parade my daughter around the restaurant and tell the patrons that she'd lost her tooth. A BUNCH of the patrons gave her quarters and my daughter was on Cloud 9! She got over $3 in quarters! She also brought her a button to wear that says she's celebrating "loosing a tooth"! We're going again in October and my daughter is hoping to lose another tooth while we're there. LOL!
There were 9 of us and we got a variety of meals. We all loved our meals and desserts and drinks. Noone was dissapointed which is not something I can say about every restaurant we visited at WDW! We highly recommend this one!
My advice would be to request a server that is "in character" when checking in. I read that once a while back here on the DIS and regretted not taking that advice. My parents were with us and my Dad was soooo looking forward to the antics and we got zip zero none!! Not even a glimpse at someone else's table, because our server had the tables surrounding us. I felt really bad for my Dad, since this was probably his last trip (not in good health) and really really wish I had requested it.