We have had the sa eexperiences, on the Wonder not many dress up, but on the magic a huge amount do dress up. I think most who dont dress up, dont know about it. We wouldnt of known about it if we hadnt been using this board. Many people dont even know this board exists. they just book and cruise.
Our first time we were on the Wonder so we did dress up and we were the ONLY people in the dining room who dressed. We got some weird looks, but it was fun. Later as we strolled the halls we got lots of nice compliments. At the party we loved it, dressing up just made it much more fun for us. I did hear some people saying Next time I am dressing up too!!! They just didnt know they could do it.
In the Magic about 2/3rds of our dining room people were dressed as pirates, including the waiters which was great. we got lots of compliments as we walked around that evening. 4 of our group of 6 dressed up, next time th eothers want to dress up to.
so i say GO FOR IT!!!! dont worry how many are dressed up, just do what you feel comfortable with and enjoy!!mom x4,grandma x4