I'm going with both Randy and Stan at STVS
I would say that whilst STVS prices are comparable to Disney we went with Stan for the quality, the effects, the reputation and more importantly the post wedding price for our guests. - Disney want to charge $325 for every DVD not already pre-ordered so if someone sees the DVD after the wedding and then decides to purchase one it really sets them back. Stan charges $55 big difference.
It's true that Disney don't offer negatives or proofs unlike Randy however they do offer on-line viewing for your guests which Randy doesn't have in place, but this was not a show stopper for us.
With Disney your 4x6 proofs, or presentation images, are included in your custom photo package. In April of this year, they converted totally to digital so they no longer utilize film or film cameras. Disney feels that the quality with high-resolution digital far surpasses that of film. You can purchase a low-resolution CD of all your images for $75 at anytime. And you can purchase high-resolution CD's of your images three years after your event, which will be May 2007, at the current market price at that time, although they failed to tell me what that price is at this moment in time.
That said Disney want to charge me $175 for a break between reception and dessert party Randy is just charging me $150 and I have him all day. Randy's price, quality and reputation won us over. Also included in our package is an Engagement shoot which we are having at the Yacht Club in December - we did think about going with Disney for a honeymoon shoot in the Magic Kingdom but we decided to ask CM's to take pictures of us in the MK and we've got little gifts for them to say thank you
We wanted to spread our own Pixie Dust
Forgot to add that friends of mine had Rick and their photos looked awesome I'm pretty sure he's as good value as Randy.