Originally posted by TWIRLYWIG
...I just ordered my Paramount tickets. I thought that they would be treated the same as any other 7-day hopper...
They are like any other 7 day PHP's as far as using them for the 7 major and 4 plus admissions at WDW goes. Where they have a major difference comes when you go to upgrade them as you are planning to do.
Example: You buy the 7 day PHP from Paramount for $301. You made out very well since the same ticket from at Disney's advance purchase price would have been $326.97. You saved nearly $26 and you got a free breakfast, too. Nice going!
But now you go to Disney and decide that you want to upgrade to an AP. Disney will only give you credit for the wholesale price that it sold that ticket to Paramount for. A good rule of thumb is subtract 12-15% from what you paid and you should be in the neighborhood of what you'll get credit for. So your $301 ticket will get approximately $265 (on the high side) worth of credit unused, even less if used at all. Why don't you get the entire amount of what you paid Paramount? Because they add a profit margin and their shipping costs to the wholesale price and Disney isn't about to credit you for that.
Disney charges $392.99 for the AP. So now you will have to pay $392.99 minus $265 = $127.99 to upgrade the ticket to an AP. Since you already paid $301 to Paramount and now you'll pay Disney $127.99 more to upgrade to the AP, you will have paid $428.99 out of pocket to get there. Even figuring in your breakfast voucher at $20, you'll still lose about $17 in the deal. You would have been better off in the long run to wait and buy your AP from Disney and pay for the character breakfast if you still wanted it.
My figures are not accurate to the penny but should be fairly close.
Buying and using the tickets as is from a wholesaler is a good move. Upgrading them to an AP never is. Not only will you lose any discount you got by buying from the wholesaler but you'll pay the dollar amount equivilent to the profit margin and shipping a second time to Disney. You can't come out ahead doing this transaction. You'd be much better off waiting and buying the AP directly from Disney in the first place.