We did a 7 night with Celebrity and a 3 night DCL in 2008. The service was similar, maybe better on Celebrity. However, for the family, DCL wins every time. The kids club, the Disney experience, shows etc are fantastic.
CC was good, but being from Australia, nothing we don't have here (other than an underwater Mickey!). Nassau was a dump. We did get profanity on our whiteboard too. But it was still a great cruise. We liked it being casual. We don't cruise to dress up, we can do that at work! I didn't see any tank tops, but I think shorts are perfectly acceptable for the bahamas!
I did have 2nd thoughts about our upcoming 12night Baltic with DCL as everyone kept saying we must be nuts to pay so much extra for Disney, but with young kids we think it is worth it. Once they are teens we will probably go elsewhere, but atm the "magic" is priceless IMO.
CC was good, but being from Australia, nothing we don't have here (other than an underwater Mickey!). Nassau was a dump. We did get profanity on our whiteboard too. But it was still a great cruise. We liked it being casual. We don't cruise to dress up, we can do that at work! I didn't see any tank tops, but I think shorts are perfectly acceptable for the bahamas!
I did have 2nd thoughts about our upcoming 12night Baltic with DCL as everyone kept saying we must be nuts to pay so much extra for Disney, but with young kids we think it is worth it. Once they are teens we will probably go elsewhere, but atm the "magic" is priceless IMO.