Picked up our minivan at MCO tonight with Alamo.
I asked about the insider policy for those who were long time members and the guy at the desk told me it wasn't true but to speak to a manager. I spoke to Kevin outside who was very nice. He understands the policy was that all rentals made by alamo insiders before May 14 are grandfathered in - not for rentals made after that date.
I am not able to read the fine print on the link posted earlier about this and tried searching the current insider Ts and Cs but didn't find anything.
If anyone is expecting to use this for their 2nd driver, I would recommend you bring a copy of their policy with you.