The Orlando Sentinel has an annual Foodie Award that they bestow on area restaurants. They do a nice job of polling their readers for their favorites in a broad variety of categories as well as identifying their food critics' choices, along with runners-up in several categories. I think it's surprising that some chains make the critics' list. The 2009 Foodie Award winners, with addresses, can be found at
http://www.orlandosentinel.com/entertainment/restaurants/orl-foodies-2009,0,3642824.htmlpage.
I'm interested in, but have not gone to, the restaurants owned by a local family-owned restaurant company called Talk of the Town Restaurants. They own Johnnie's Hideaway at Crossroads in Lake Buena Vista (off route 535), Charley's Steakhouse (there are three in the area), FishBones on Sand Lake Road, Moonfish on West Sand Lake, and Vito's Chop House on International Drive. Lot's of people on these boards mention at least some of these restaurants as being very good. We like the food and atmosphere at Bahama Breeze (Vineland Ave. and International Drive locations).
The Celebration Town Tavern, in downtown Celebration, is a favorite of our's, too.
Bon appetit!
Dick Taylor