Let's see.........Thoroughly Modern Millie was "thoroughly" enjoyable--a very fun, entertaining show and the lead (whose name escapes me right now) is awesome! I've heard that the Producers is very good. RENT is VERY good, but a little "racy" as far as topic, language,etc., but if you're not taking kids, it's fine. You may be able to get those tickets at the two-fers booth. Beauty & the Beast was great, but since you're already seeing one Disney show........... You really can't go wrong with just about any show. If you like something "different" , we recently took our teens to see Blue Man Group and had a total blast! I highly recommend this show. Have fun! NYC is the greatest city in the world.