I understand. I am the family "Disney Freak", everyone knows it. Last year, SIL decided to take her daughter, for a # of reasons, she asked her parents to come along as well. When I heard she was considering the trip, I offered to help and give any info I could. I was careful not to sound like I would take over the trip because I know how independent SIL is. Well, she never asked me anything, nor mentioned it to me, until after she had her sister's husband book the trip for her. Needless to say, his Disney knowledge was very minimal. I felt offended, because I like to help people, and I LOVE to share my WDW knowledge. Helping people plan trips is really fun for me. Anyway, they paid WAYYYYYYYYY too much money for the trip and planned nothing. The crowds were really heavy and they hardly accomplished anything. Went on very few rides, saw very few characters, spent most of their time sitting miserably unhappy in their hotel room they didn't like.
Fast forward a few months when her parents, my inlaws, went to WDW with our family. I planned everything. I made all the plans. MIL told me several times how much better our trip was than the previous trip. She also could not believe how much we accomplished. She said we did things they didn't even know existed. That made me feel really good. I just feel bad for the poor little girl who missed out on what should have been a really great trip because her mother did things the way she did.
I'm not saying my way is the best, or that I am the perfect WDW trip planner, but I don't understand why some people choose to go the blind way when they know there is another option, with a lit path. For what it's worth, the first time I took my family, I asked people that I knew had been several times, and got lots of advice, and right from the very first trip, we had a blast. I had been about 5 times growing up, so I knew what I was getting into, but still asked for ideas and advice. I am so glad I did. I guess now, I just want to return the favor.