Being an ex-smoker...I get both arguments. I have asthma and I worry about having to be around it a lot, too. Yet, I am going to just take a chance and hope things go well...bringing meds with me of course. Surely DCL has thought of the same things we have mentioned but they have to try to please people too, so I can understand their hands being tied, so to speak. While I don't encourage smoking, that is a good idea that some might want to use perhaps for the trip only, at least. This way they can have their fix and not have to hear complaints. If us fat, sweaty people don't toot in the elevators, how else then can we get them to ourselves? Hey, it made it to page 5!!