I chose the Polynesian last year for a trip with my DD(3 1/2 at the time) while I was 6 months pregnant because of the location. I wanted the ease of monorail or boat to MK and monorail to Epcot. I had been to WDW on 7 previous trips and had stayed offsite, POR, BWV, Ft Wilderness cabins, Dolphin, & YC. I enjoyed all the resorts and would stay at any again except the offsite one until I stayed at the Poly. I LOVED it. It was such a relaxing place. I recently asked my DD what her favorite thing was about our trip and she'd usually say the monorail, or Figment but this time she said the "night". She too loved just walking around the resort at night with the music and tiki torches. It really is magical. I had read a number of negative reviews before my trip and would at times have 2nd thoughts. I am so glad I stayed at the Poly. I can't wait to go with my DH, DD(now 4 1/2), DS(turns 3 on trip) and new baby(will be nearly 1).
My DH thinks he's seen it all at WDW because he went once with me for 3 days. He thinks he'll be bored for 5 nights. I can't wait for him to experience the Polynesian. I know he'll love it and wait til he sees Disney through the eyes of his children.