We have been there twice so far for dinner (January and February) We thought the whole experience...atmosphere/decor, service and food was all good. WE also really enjoyed being able to have a glass of wine with a meal in the Magic Kingdom.
We have had French onion soup and meat tray for appetizers...loved 'em. Cornish hen (was OK, not great) as well as the seafood pasta dish (good) and the pork chop (good chop, with fabulous mac & cheese side dish)
We have had the strawberry cupcake, the lemon cupcake, the triple chocolate and the cream puff with chocolate. Also got a bonus "the gray stuff"
Loved the cupcakes. The cream puff was OK, not great. The chocolate dessert was over the top sweet. The "gray stuff"...OK, but wouldn't order it as a dessert if they offered to sell it (usually it is just given for special occasions...you cannot order it. I think we happened to hit a night near closing time when they had too much left over, because shortly before closing they just brought out trays of it & started delivering one plate to every table...most tables had already been served dessert and were getting checks.)
Will we go back: you bet. In fact, we'll be back there in March.