Same here! When my boys were little it was all about proximity to MK, so when I could afford it, WL and CR were the way to go (no need to wake up kids and fold up that dang stroller!)
Once they outgrew the stroller, they loved the values - the over the top theming and the food courts captivated them. Given my budget as a single parent I was happy to go along with that. To this day, AS Sports is my younger son's favorite, largely due to the great memories we created there.
And now that they are teens, for my older son it's all about luxury in dining options and chilling by the pool. He is the reason we have now done Poly CL twice. Personally, other than the lounge view, it doesn't grab me, but I get to him it is the quintessential experience. And I will say I do like the ease of catching the monorail over to EP for dinners.
This summer, I have no idea where we will land....I fell in love with YC CL last summer, so if there is a good discount, I will jump on it (and add a few starting days at Sports). But if not, I suspect it will be a mix of Sports and whatever deluxe has the best deal for our dates - at least that way I know both kids will get some of the experience they enjoy.