Originally posted by taylor1293
IMO, no HIFS is not worth $184 a night. It is a family style, budget resort. However, do I think you deserve a refund? No. Not for the reasons you listed. I think refunds are necessary for issues such as unclean rooms, rude staff, problems with the rooms itself, and so on. I don't think you should receive one for not having enough storage space and not having a chair by the pool.
Teresa
Teresa:
First off, I was not asking for a "refund". I didn't want any of my money back. What I wanted was a reduction in the cost of the rooms because that's what was causing my displeasure with my family's experience.
If you're looking at cars and are being quoted $60,000 for a BMW, you likely feel pretty good about it. If you're being quoted $60,000 for a Hyundai, and found out that it's really only worth $30,000, you likely feel bad about it and would stop the transaction before it took place, wouldn't you?
Same thing here. Betwen the DIS boards and the fact that the hotel is filled with nothing but "suites", I was led to believe that this was an upper-moderate facility and not any sort of discount budget hotel. Truth is, it's somewhere in the middle.
Right or wrong, I thought I was going to get all the Disney amenities and more space for the same price as a Disney moderate hotel. It made sense to me- lure the $180+ a-night crowd away from a Disney moderate by charging them the same rate, keeping all the amenities the same, and giving them triple the space as a deal-breaker. That's what did it for me. Instead of squeezing into one room at the CBR as intended, I got a full suite at HIFS. I expected to lose the 'magic' of course; the little Disney things that make a stay on site so appealing. What I didn't expect to lose were the basics in upper-moderate hotels as detailed in prior postings.
It's a matter of perception. If you perceive the HIFS to be on par with CBR or any other Disney moderate hotel you're going to be disappointed. If you are paying CBR prices, you're going to be flabbergasted. If you perceive the HIFS to be on equal footing to a basic Holiday Inn or any number of $99-a-nite hotels then you're going to be thrilled beyond belief.
I will not go into detail, but the management of the HIFS did the right thing and made this customer feel much better about his experience this past week. They have also given me the impression that they hear where I'm coming from and that the Nickelodeon-ized version of the HIFS will be what I envisioned the current HIFS to be - an upper-moderate suite hotel catering to families that can afford high Disney prices and demand Disney level amenities and service levels. That said, those of you looking for a bargain might look elsewhere next year as the pizza party coupons and Entertainment book discounting might be (thankfully) on the way out the door. Some of us want to pay more to get more. I wasn't afforded that opportunity this year, but next year sounds promising so it looks like we'll be back at the new, improved, and upgraded NFS in 2005.