I just can't vote. I don't think you should do this.
Sadly, I do understand just what you are saying. Our family doctor is Indian and he is always commenting that nobody wants him for a doctor and half the people who come in as a new patient and are given an appt with him ask for someone else for their next appt.
If they go to that first appointment with him, and ask for someone else for the second, it most likely means they have a problem with HIM, not with his name. People are allowed to change doctors, and he should be looking at what he's doing or not doing, rather than just assuming it's b/c of his ancestry.
Practitioners can seem very different to different people...to one person they are the most caring wonderful people, while to others they are demonic. My best friend and I see the same dentist, we loooove him. He's conservative about doing anything, he likes to wait and see. I suggested him to hubby...hubby hates him. Thinks he's a scam artist. Can't figure out why he's so kind to my friend and I and acts so sweet with us, when he can't see it at all.
I felt immense sadness when I read your post ...
I would urge you to focus on your medical and relationship skills, your last name should not define your professional skills.
Same here. Especially when I realized you're changing you FIRST name as well.
And I agree, focus on your skills.
I'm not trying to be picky, but I find it strange that your whole post is about names - it includes a list of last names and a first name mentioned at least twice - and you failed to capitalize the first letter of any of them. It just looks odd to me to see names, either first or last, with a first letter in lowercase.
The only things she did capitalize were the initials of the country. She seems to have the no-capitals style, which plenty of people do. So it shouldn't be a surprise that the names in the poll were lower-case as well.
Yes I'm a lil country and live in the boondocks (and this'll probably start it's own thread or life on it's own) but I know of no man that has ever taken his wifes surname. Do you? And honestly I *think* Hollywood is the only place I know of where a woman will just keep her own name throughout the marriage. Yup all of the men around here are Neanderthals who expect it.
Once my MIL has passed on, hubby plans to change his last name to mine. He has NO respect for his father (or grandfather or great grandfather, all of whom weren't nice people), and doesn't wish to have that name anymore. But his mom would have a HUGE problem with it, and he doesn't want to do that to her.
Which is weird, because in her culture of origin women do not, traditionally, change their last names. None of her sisters changed their names upon marriage, and her brother's wife didn't either.
And I haven't changed my last name in almost 8 years of marriage, and definitely wouldn't do so to change it to hubby's! Not that my dad is any great dude, but the others in my paternal family are pretty cool, and I like the name.
People on message boards have no stake in the outcome of the actions they advise others to take. They're just killing time. With no knowledge of the details of anyone's real life, they'd dispensing "words of wisdom" based on suppositions of their own experience rather than the OP's experience.
I don't understand it when people who spend time on message boards giving opinions denigrate the advice and opinions of people on message boards.
Do you REALLY think that the advice given face to face is that much better? If I'd relied solely on friends, I wouldn't have followed my heart and taken hubby back, I wouldn't have had anyone to work out my feelings about everything with (friends wanting me to just dump him and move on and not wanting to hear about anything I was going through), because they have WAY stronger opinions than strangers do. Later when I was going through some nasty stuff, stuff I did talk about with hubby quite a bit, people online got me through b/c the opinions of real life "friends" were incredibly insensitive and uncaring.
Why bother with message boards if you don't actually think people CARE or try to HELP others on them? I know I don't have the best rep here, but what I say I say because I care deeply about the situation and I'm trying to help.
Personally I would feel like I was disrespecting my ancestors and everything they built the name into just because it wasn't "white" enough for me.
OP verified it later, but even when you posted this there was nothing to indicate she wasn't white. There are plenty of "obvious" names that are still caucasian.
There are a good many senior citizens in our country who aren't "bigots" or "haters". Many don't hear well to begin with, throw in an accent that's unfamiliar to them and it's a mess. So...when they hear they're to have a visit with a doctor having a name they can't pronounce or is "unusual" to them, many simply freak and refuse. Often times it's that simple...just fearful of not being able to understand what is being said to them.
For what's it's worth, all my doctors are foreign and I'd never switch to see someone with an "American" sounding name, but I've had roommates from Thailand, China and Brazil so I catch what people are saying rather quickly. I do remember what it was like the first few days of having a Chinese roommate and it WAS difficult to catch everything she said. A senior citizen has but a few moments to understand and what they're hearing is *vitally important* so I sympathize.Yes, a "foreign" sounding name can be intimidating to some, especially seniors.
Thank you thank you for saying that. My MIL herself is Korean, and has never become fluent in English. Therefore it's important that she sees people who either speak English well OR can speak Korean.
She had a hospital stay where this became very important. The doctor on call for all but the last day of her stay was of the same background as the doctor on her last day. Both were female, both were basically competent. But one could speak English clearly and slowly, and did not take it as an insult if any of us needed her to repeat something, while the other was the opposite.
The doctor caring for her for most of her stay was incomprehensible. That was even for me, and I"m usually good with accents. She spoke ridiculously fast, which she probably did to keep moving, BUT if asked to repeat she would nearly have a tantrum (each time) and then wouldn't slow down until the third time you begged her to. So she spent twice, even three times as long with a patient, because of this time-saving thing she was doing.
On the last day, the doctor taking over was nearly 7 hours late to see, and discharge, MIL, because (and she stated this) she had spent the day calming down the patients who had been dealing with the other one. She indicated that this was nothing new, when she worked after the first one. The first one was just that brusque, rude, and absolutely un-understandable.
MIL couldn't understand her at all, and she couldn't understand MIL. The second doctor could EASILY understand MIL, I got to stop translating what she was saying on that last day (DS, who was 4 or 5 at the time, and I got to spend many hours each day with her to make sure everyone understood everyone else).
Because of this experience, because she's SCARED of it happening again, MIL is frightened of seeing doctors of that background. The first doctor was NOT fluent in English, at least not that anyone listening to her could tell, and IMO if you're going to work with the public and speak to them, and speak about literal life or death things with them, you *have to be fluent*.
Sometimes, IMO, it's OK to try to protect yourself by looking at names.
We try to find Korean doctors for her, it's just easier on everyone. She can go by herself and she'll understand what they tell her.
She also does have one big prejudice, and won't see doctors of one certain background (not the same as the background not-mentioned above). But that was because of occupation of her home country when she was a child, and the death of her father after spending a year in a concentration camp (the term isn't just used for the Holocaust). I think we should allow those whose countries were occupied to be angry with those from the occupying country.
I still don't think people should change their names, though.
my parents are straight from eastern europe. my mom is an executive at a pharmaceutical company, and she has mentioned several times that clients or other executives will think less of her because she has an accent and because she's a woman in a male-dominated field (but that's another issue), despite her top education and skills. i asked her what she thought and she wasn't thrilled with the idea, but she understands my reasoning.
all that said, how do you pick a new dentist/doctor if not by name? i check where they attended medical/dental school and did their residency, but i know not everyone does that.
It doesn't seem that your mom is having problems *because of her name* though. Accents can be hard for people. There are plenty of people in this world who just cannot understand accents. I didn't realize that I was actually *good* at it until I moved somewhere else (I grew up in a bit of a melting pot, though nothing like NYC is) and found LOTS of people who couldn't understand even the lightest accent at all. (even though those people had mystifyingly strong accents themselves LOL) And your mom also has the male-dominated industry thing going against her.
Our successful doctor-choosings have been by referrals from people that we trust. That share the same beliefs as us, the same backgrounds in what we want from healthcare people. When I've gone by "oh I like that name, they sound like nice people", or just by the list of people covered by insurance, we have had SERIOUS problems. Referrals from trusted people are 100% the best, for us.
I may have missed it, but has any one addressed the issue that patients may find it weird that the name on your degree is different from the name you give out? Most doctors that I know have their degree(s) posted somewhere.
Or that I wouldn't be able to look up your name with the medical board (here, it would be the Royal College, not sure what it is for you)?
If you do have the "also known as" option with the medical board, I'd find it very weird that you changed both your first and last name. Last name, I'd assume marriage, so I wouldn't find that weird, but first name? I'd start wondering what you were hiding.
Until your post I didn't realize she was changing her first name as well.
As far as I know you can have your diplomas changed if you wish...at least I think you can.
I picked Carter because I thought it sounded best with doctor as you'll often be called Doctor Carter (or other given last name).
I think I watched too much ER in the '90s to really trust a Dr Carter... (OK he became a better doctor but at the beginning, yikes!)