If the boardwalk is the least disney for you, what is the most disney?
Great question. I will break it down to our favs at the levels.
Deluxe: AKL - the atmosphere, the anaimals, Jiko's. Overall, we love the feel here we like the quiet nature of the resort. Compared to BW, where you had to join the crowd on the boardwalk to eat or get a drink.
Moderate: Enjoy Caribbean Beach's pool, but seems a lot of the rooms even though just recently redone seem worn, especially the bathrooms.
We also enjoy Coronado even those it has little Disney theming.
Value: Pop is our favorite for this level as rooms and food goes. All Star movies has the best Theme in my opinion, but the location and feel we get at Pop gives it the nod.
The main negative about the BW feel, is it didn't seem like a resort on its own, it truly did feel like you were on the boardwalk. So, they accomplished their point, but growing up going to the NJ and Maryland shores and staying ont he boardwalk this is not what we look for at WDW.
This is just one person's perspective of the resorts. We have gone almost continuously since 1991 and have stay at almost every resort, each has positives and negatives from everyone's point of view.
No matter where you stay, you will have a great time.