Sherry E
Currently tag-less...
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2008
You know, besides the problem of the overlap hours when regular park visitors AND the MHP ticket holders are sharing the park, I think the issue of the crowds at MHPs gets into how you frame what you want to do at the MHP. You can think of there being two types of party-goers:
1) Locals who did not come for a whole day at the park, and just showed up for the party, so that the party hours are both their time for Halloween magic AND regular park time. These are the people who are gung-ho about getting on rides as much as anything that is exclusive to the MHP event. This is why Star Tours, Indy, et al have massive lines during the party.
and
2) People who are visiting from out of town for at *least* three days in the park, one of which includes the MHP. They have other opportunities to ride those popular rides.
I assume that most people who come to this thread and are considering attending an MHP are in category (2). So if you are, my advice would be to use regular park times to do rides (especially Haunted Mansion, because the line is so insane during the party) and focus on the party-only offerings during the party, like the villains who perhaps were not out during the day, the parade (or cavalcade, if you prefer), the AMAZEBALLS fireworks (which, it felt like, *every* single last person at DL came to see, so just come prepared to deal with a total crushing crunch of people that dissipates all too slowly afterwards), people and costume watching, and, of course, trick-or-treating!
Now, my family did the Ultimate Experience, where we took the Happiest Haunts tour before joining the MHP already in progress. So that did get us on five big rides (Matterhorn, HM, Space Mountain Ghost Galaxy, Thunder Mountain, and Tower of Terror), which probably helped us feel we had gotten our ride fix before we dove into the party, meeting villains, and letting the kids go crazy running through the treat trails. (We ended up filling to the brim one of those very large reusable grocery bags along with the modest bags provided.) But I don't think it is at all necessary. Just party at the party, coming after a rest if you can so you can easily stay to the very end, when some of the locals have left so the lines do get a little better if you want to catch a last ride or two. (Again, not HM, ST, or Indy.) Hmm, although the locals leaving might more be for weekday parties than Friday ones. Worked for us on Wednesday, Oct 31, so maybe this year's Thursday Halloween will work similarly.
I wonder if most party-goers are in category (1), making the price of the MHP ticket more akin to a "twilight" ticket, where you're just paying for half of a day's attendance (although surely many of the local attendees are also AP holders, who have effectively paid for an entire park day when they bought their AP), rather than those in category (2), who have to pay for the party as an extra on top of their regular admission and who therefore want it to be more like a private, exclusive party with fewer people.
What do you think, Sherry? You seem like someone who goes to both H'ween and Holiday time more to soak up the ambiance rather than thrill ride, and as a local AP holder, have other opportunities to come and seek out rides.
TigerlilyAJ --
Normally I would have tried to reply to you right away..but I got caught up in watching (Next) Food Network Star! I love that show!
You made some very good, insightful points!
Yes, you're right -- I'm not really focused on rides when I make my Halloween and holiday visits to DLR. Actually, the older I get the less I care about rides in general, believe it or not! I visit the park(s) for Halloween Time and the holiday season to celebrate those holidays, soak up the atmosphere and take many, many photos. Also, I guess you could call my trips "fact-finding missions" or information-gathering missions, as I try to observe little details and things that could be of interest for people in this Superthread and in the Christmas Superthread down the road.
I am considered a local to anyone who lives out of state or out of the country, but I'm not really a local, geographically. I'm in L.A. County, while Disneyland is in Orange County. So I typically don't go to the parks outside of Halloween Time and the holiday season unless there is a very specific, special circumstance that brings me there -- such as the Cars Land/Buena Vista Street preview in June 2012.
If I don't go on any other rides the entire season(s), and if I didn't go to the MHP, I would always at least make a point of going on Haunted Mansion Holiday (and It's a Small World Holiday during the holidays). I like to keep up to date on what is happening with those particular ride overlays, if there are any new things added in, etc.
I agree that a portion of locals may hit the rides during the actual party because the lines are perceived to be shorter. However, I also know of people -- not necessarily all "locals," but people who live far away and still go to the parks a few times each year -- who have no interest in hitting the rides during the MHP. They feel that those rides are there all the time and they can go on them any time, so they want to do things at the party that are party-exclusives, such as getting photos with characters, seeing the fireworks and Cavalcade and collecting candy!
I also think that there are people who are at DLR on multi-day visits who do hit the rides on party nights because the lines are long during the day and they hope that the party will offer shorter lines. They may not get another chance to come back to DLR for a long time, so if they can get on some of the DL rides without hideous waits they will take advantage of it.
I know that if I am going to pay for the MHP -- and I don't think it's something I need to do every year, but I plan to do it this year and next year, on Halloween, because it will be a Friday -- I want to do things that I would not be doing in my daily life outside of Disneyland, and also things that I can't do on a normal Halloween Time day in the park. That includes trick or treating! As an adult, where else besides Disneyland do you get to abandon all "age bias" with glee and trick or treat to your heart's content?
I also like to roam around at the party and check out the interesting treat trails and stations, not only for the candy but just to see where they are set up, how fast the lines move, if there are any extra decorations, etc. I don't really spend my party time on rides.
I agree that a large percentage of humanity in general is camped out and waiting for Halloween Screams fireworks! They are awesome and they should be seen, but a lot of people do wait for them! I skipped the Cavalcade last time around, but maybe I will try to see it this year.
I would also choose to stay until the very end of the party if I am paying money to be there, but you're right -- especially on the earlier weeknights there may be some local guests who have to get home a bit early to prepare for work the next day. On Fridays, though, all bets are off and everyone is staying until the bitter end!
I agree with the advice about skipping the rides and focusing on the party-specific things (unless this is your only chance to go on rides, or they are a big priority for you). Even though the lure of the shorter lines for certain (not all) rides is tempting, you are paying for a party and all the trappings that come with it so it makes sense to get all that you can of those offerings!
One other thing I love to do is just look at the costumes! Some folks are very creative and talented when they make their costumes, like the folks dressed as Haunted Mansion ghosts, complete with a wheelchair decked out as a Doom Buggy. Other costumes had me laughing out loud, like the guy in the giant Crayola crayon costume.
I remember standing in line at a treat station and saying to Liza/funatdisney -- as we observed this enormous blob of fur and feathers waddling along up ahead of us - "I love that a giant yellow chicken is just moseying through the treat line. Gotta love trick or treating at Disneyland!!"
With you 100% on the Halloween decoration ideas, Sherry! Basically, the possibilities for both CL and BVS seem pretty endless to me in that department, and since they did such a good job on the Christmas themes in both areas, I can only imagine the fun they could bring to them at Halloween... I wish I could've gone to MHP back when it was at DCA, before CL and BVS. As fun as the DL version sounds, the idea of the party happening in DCA pre-remodel I find kind of interesting. Of course, I'm sure the DL MHP will definitely be cool (DL is still my favorite park, even if DCA at nighttime is pretty magnificent). Anywho, I did have a question I was hoping someone could answer about the fireworks? I was wondering where's the best spot to view the show. Hopefully someone knows a "secluded" (using the word lightly, of course, being that we're talking about DL and all...) part with a nice view? We usually see the fireworks from the concierge at the DLH, so this is a little new to us.
DisneyFan3113 --
I actually enjoyed the party when it used to be held in DCA. It didn't feel as crowded to me as it feels in Disneyland, and it gave DCA a reason to be decorated for the season so that Disneyland wasn't the only park with Halloween decor! I loved the candy corn-colored CALIFORNIA letters in front of DCA! I liked that the Villains had photo spots during the daytime in the Hollywood Backlot area. I loved the candy corn hanging from the Golden Gate Bridge, and stuck in various planters.
Now, even though a full-fledged Candy Corn Acres might not be possible, it seems that something more could be done with DCA for Halloween than what has been going on for the last few years. I think the treat trails in Disneyland are interesting during the party, but I kind of wish it were still being held in DCA. Disney could do an all-Halloween World of Color too!
In the Halloween Time call-in show and podcast from last year (I posted the link on the previous page, I think -- it's in the post about treats), there is discussion on where to stand for Halloween Screams fireworks. Maybe that will help somewhat, if you get a chance to listen.
I could tell you where I stood for the fireworks, but that's not necessarily where I would recommend anyone to stand -- so I will defer to TigerlilyAJ or someone else who may have scored a better viewing spot!