Miss Traveler I am a fan of both of these resorts..although I will say GF is my fave too...
While the GF is just that Grand.. which you already know since you are a fan...
... the CR is truly a WDW classic...the new rooms are what I would call modern elegance..and and while the grounds are not as lovely as those of the GF...but still well kept and Disneyish ( I think that I made up a new word??? LOL!!!) IMO...the view from those tower rooms cannot be beat...I am a fan of the Bay view..and love watching the EWP in the evenings...and the surise in the morning..there are folks that must have the MK view..and I can understand why..being able to see the castle from the vantage point of those rooms is very magical...
Also there is something very cool about watching the monorail gliding in and out of the resort...Its something you wont find anywhere else...
HTH a little....both are beautiful resorts...and I am sure you will enjoy which ever you choose...