We have stayed quite a few times at the Movies and we like it there (our new favorite Value resort is the POP Century though).
Congrats on your 2 year anniversary. We are celebrating 20 this year.
The first year we went we stayed offsite, we had a good time. The next year we stayed onsite at the Shades of Green Military hotel and liked it so much better. The next time we stayed at the All Star Movies and we swore we would NEVER stay offsite again. The movies is so "DISNEY" and it's so much more convenient and you feel like your at the parks at your hotel.
You'll love it - Enjoy!