Not that accomodating. When you are only two of you, they make your ride with strangers. They won't let you ride with just your party of two like you used to be able to do. Those seats don't really seat four people well and I find it wrong that I have to be pressed up against a strangers hips on a ride. I don't even like sitting four across with my family of four and we used to say that we were two groups of two...no longer an option.
^^This exactly as our experience. We rode on Oct 6 (
MNSSHP night). CM directed us to row 4, where there were already 2 adults. We asked to switch rows (as we're both Pooh-sized), but CM said no. (We didn't think to ask to wait for the next boat). CM filled the boat completely...so the "sardine packing" look certainly applied. I'd read on the Boards since the last refurb getting wet was now possible, so I was glad to not be in the front row. There was some water on the floor & seats, so I chose to hold onto our bags (party night goodies and other personal items), and I'm glad I did. Now, I was sure my Pooh size was helping our boat list a bit, but I was astounded to see the WAVE of water that came up and onto the front row of guests as we went down the drop. Shrieks all around ensued. And now the boat had standing water in it once it leveled. The ride, of course, got stuck near the end (we were about the 4th boat back from the end), but I don't think it was down for a significant time that night.
And, to note, the drop was changed during the last refurb (see item #3 in article below). Nothing major, but apparently enough that uneven weight distribution in the boat can create a "splash" per the article: http://www.****************.com/news/20150926/30564/5-amazing-changes-pirates-caribbean (Apologies if I'm not supposed to link to an article; Mods please remove if needed.)
Overall I'd agree with many of the posters. You may get wet on POTC. You may get REALLY wet. I'm not sure this is clear at the outset of the ride, given for 30+ years you maybe got limited splash from the drop or cannon fire. CMs may or may not be overloading boats / be accommodating / be allowing for 'wet' or 'not wet' choices. Your feet and/or seat may be dry at the beginning but there's no guarantee it will be after your ride. Timing of day may well be a factor.
Not a rant and not an apologist on this topic. Just grateful for the DIS for allowing readers to share their experiences/concerns.