Cape May Cafe
Located in Beach Club, Cape May had a smaller, but delicious buffet selection. There is a fair amount of seafood offered, with certain dishes that are rotated out on various days of the week. The breakfast offers a character dining experience. I chose dinner. To say I ate well is a complete understatement.
Plate 1: Hand carved strip loin, mashed potatoes, steamed clams, paella, and fried clam strips.
So much good food on one plate! The strip loin was cooked to my liking, somewhere around a medium rare. It was incredibly juicy and flavorful. The meat has a mixture of seasonings that had been cooked into a nice, savory crust. The seasonings also imparted a very nice flavor to the meat without being overpowering. It was so good I kept going back for more. The potatoes were also excellent. It was a terrific mix of creamy and chunky, with a peppery flavor. As I would find out, these needed no gravy to add flavor. They were very good on their own. The steamed clams weren't anything too special. They had a bit of flavor but were otherwise forgettable. It tasted like they had a buttery flavor added to them. Not bad in any kind of way, just slightly bland. The paella was way overly salty. It had a good mix of clams, shrimp, and sausage to give it a variety of texture, but the salt was overpowering. It was the one thing on the plate that I couldn't finish. The fried clams weren't bad, just a little generic. I dipped them in cocktail sauce, so flavor wasn't much of an issue, but like their steamed brethren, they didn't really stand out. Overall, a pretty tasty first plate.
Plate 2: My next plate was all peel and eat shrimp. I tore right into it without taking a photo. I didn't realize this until there were about three shrimp left. Oops, I'll have to make up for that one!
Plate 3: More of my favorites. The peel and eat shrimp were nicely seasoned and, thankfully, quite plentiful. It was one of the spots that people were crowded around on each trip. They were a good sized shrimp, and surprisingly uniform across the board. They've been deveined, which I truly appreciate. They were excellent, as a plate and a half can attest to. There isn't much more that needs to be said about the strip steak. It's still delicious. I will add that I missed the creamy horseradish sauce on the first trip, but noticed it on this plate. It was the perfect complement to the meat. Just enough of a kick to add a new dynamic to the meat, but not overly hot, as some horseradish sauces can be. It was excellent! The corn bread was soft and tasted pretty good. It was on the sweeter side of the corn bread spectrum, with a texture that was closer in consistency to cake rather than the more crumbly and dryer nature of cornbread that I'm accustomed to. I liked it though. I think I would have preferred the more crumbly variety though.
Plate 4: A recreation. I tried to get as close to my meal at Chefs de France for an honest comparison. In theory, the "buffet blandness" should be easily trumped by a restaurant specializing in these items. That's not the case here. Right off the bat, everything is seasoned in a superior manner here. There is flavor abound, especially in these items. In truth, I didn't have much of any intentions to eat green beans, especially at a buffet. It can be cheap filler. However, these were amazing! They had an incredibly fresh snap to them, almost as if they
were fresh *gasp*! They had a light citrus zing to them as well, probably because they were seasoned at some point in the cooking process. I did, in all fairness, add just a dash of salt and pepper, but they were nearly perfect on their own. It's amazing what seasoning food can do to their flavor. The meat was superior, hands down. It wasn't even close. The exterior crust added to the natural flavor of the meat. Visually, it was far more appealing, with a bright pink center and a fading gradient into browns. I know color isn't a flavor, but the first thing you do for any dish is eat it with your eyes, and my eyes found this to be delicious. The potatoes were also vastly superior to the au gratin variety I had at Chefs. The texture of the mashed potatoes was actual mash, not mush. The salt and pepper made them very tasty. What wasn't so hot was the gravy. Chefs wins in this arena, I suppose. I scraped off the bits of potato that had gravy on it. It really was not good. It had powdered generic brown gravy written all over it. That's a skip, all day. Still, it's interesting to see how a bit of seasoning can be so important, and how buffet food can actually be really good and not a generic and bland mess.
Dessert plate 1: Boston creme cake, caramel flan, pistachio cheesecake, red velvet cupcake, and some kind of lemon cake. I got every item on the dessert bar except the flourless chocolate cake and some other kind of chocolate concoction. These were all amazing. The Boston creme cake was moist and delicious, with a wonderful creme layer. It was very tasty. The flan was fantastic. It was a little denser than I'm used to flan being, but it tasted so good. The caramel hit is subtle, but really comes in at the end. The fruit on top was fresh and vibrant. It was so delicious. And speaking of delicious, pistachio cheesecake, where have you been all of my life? Honestly? So amazing. So creamy and delectable. The chocolate cookie crust was the perfect complement to the silky smooth pistachio cheese cake filling. Amazing! The red velvet cupcake was pretty good, though after the pistachio cheesecake, I think I might have been let down that it wasn't superb. The lemon cake was very tart. It had a very familiar taste to it that I couldn't quite place, though some kind of drink came to mind. It was not bad, but nothing I'd want to try again. It was a little too tart for my palette.
Dessert plate 2: Can you tell which ones I
really liked? I had to get a few more pistachio cheesecake pieces to make sure the first, second, or third one wasn't a fluke. Nope, no fluke. Still delicious and amazing. The flan was also just as good the second time around. I want more of both, like right now.
As you can see by my overload of food, I really enjoyed Cape May Cafe. There was so much more food that I just didn't have the room to try. Their anti-pasto salad looked amazing and was almost gone every time I went back up to get some. There was some fantastic bruscetta that had the longest line on each trip. There were a few other shrimp and meat dishes that also drew large lines. In a way, I'm happy that I didn't get to try it. It gives me an excellent excuse to go back and eat there again. I also want to go on a Tuesday so that I can try their fried calamari. I love fried calamari, more than shrimp, and I'm a big shrimp fan. And of course, I need more pistachio cheesecake in my life. So delicious.