I'll preface by saying I've only tried Coronado Springs. But I loved the theming, and the view, and the dedicated buses (did not share with any other resort). The pool area (Dig Site) was just beautiful, and there were hammocks everywhere along the paths. I had a water view in Casitas 5, which was halfway between the Dig Site and El Centro. Although the walks can definitely be long, I didn't find them excessively so. My location was also very close to a bus stop...the first one to pick up/drop off, and that colored my experience towards the positive.
Mousekeeping was diligent, bell services very good, and I had towel animals every single day. I'm just lucky, I guess.