Congratulations...
We did our honeymoon trip a year ago at GF in a concierge honeymoon room. And this year we are doing our anniversary trip in a GF honeymoon room again!
Like everyone else has said, don't expect anything. If you get something, that is great. Wear the hats (we will be again, and will be totally honest that it is our anniversary).
Now, in terms of extra magic, do not underestimate how wonderful it is to hear "Congratulations!" every five minutes or less. It feels so good that complete strangers are happy for you. Pass the magic and say it to other brides.
Other guests can be the best. We were invited onto the Grand One for a wishes cruise by another guest just because they saw us in the lounge in our ears. He came over and asked us if we would mind him giving us a wedding gift... I was a little apprehensive. But, we spent the rest of the week in the lounge every night catching up and chatting about our days with him and his family (older mother who was always in the lounge and siblings). It was a great thing and we still all keep in touch. That said, I don't think that this is a "normal thing".
There were little things that CMs did too that were very nice! We recieved some magical moments certificates, a free "anything" from a ice cream vendor in Epcot, and other little things.
Here is my suggestion:
Make your own magic. This year, I have a ton of things planned for my DH. PM me for specifics or for ideas, but DH reads my posts... (hi honey) If you can do it, splure on a nice dinner or two. We are again doing an expensive trip, so another $300 to do V&A with wine pairings isn't much (especialy with free dining saving some money). There are so many things that you can do.