When I was growing up Santa left all of our gifts, and they were all wrapped. So, we never had any gifts under the tree until Christmas morning. DH didn't like that. So, in our house Santa leaves one gift - unwrapped. The rest of them are from us. Each girl has a roll of wrapping paper that I use just for them. This year DD7 has American Girl, DD3 has Disney princesses. There are no gift tags on the gifts. Now it's pretty obvious whose is whose, but as they get older their wrap will probably be similar. If we had our tree up (no tree this year) all of their gifts would be under it right now, except for what Santa brings.