I have Geico. I love it. I made one claim, an uninsured motorist hit one of my corvettes while it was parked at work. No issues with the claim.
My insurance is really cheap through Geico. I am 27, have had more than 20 tickets, a couple very bad speeding tickets, I insure a couple range rovers, a couple corvettes, and just one motorcycle currently, and my insurance is still very, very reasonable. I feel so anyways. They are by far the cheapest for motorcycles, especially my Ducati.
I love that you can call 24/7 and someone that speaks English is always there. Their app is pretty decent.
I've only had two issues. #1 Theyre always trying to add rental car reimbursement and road side assistance in my policy when I do not ask for it and I usually have to ask multiple times that they don't put it on my policy, and then I will have to check my policy on the internet to make sure. They have added it before when I haven't wanted it.
#2. This probably won't affect most people, but they won't insure exotic cars. They won't insure an Aston Martin and I would assume other exotics as well. I guess I can understand why but it's annoying. I'd like all my insurance under one roof.
I've been with them since I was like 20 or 21 maybe, when I got my first vette. I won't be going anywhere else anytime soon