This thread has taken a very upsetting turn.
The fact is, homeschool children are no more or less advanced than children who attend school just because of the way the are schooled.
To say that they are is both naive and insulting to the scores upon scores of brilliant children in both public and private educations world wide. I would hope we all can agree that there are children with wide ranges of abilities and disabilities in all walks of life and education models.
Also, I find it extremely arrogant that some people think that the rules don't apply to them. I don't care if your child is entering Harvard on a full scholarship next year; if you have to lie to get them into a class, then it is just that - a lie. You are basically saying to your child, you are better than all the other kids here and it is OK for you to lie to get what you want. IMO, raising a child with a self-serving attitude is not the way to go.
Personally, I hope they start asking for proof of age. It would solve this problem.
Lastly, as someone who can only to WDW, or anywhere else for that matter, on school vacation weeks I know how much it stinks that everything fills up quickly. But, to say that homeschooled children should only go during homeschool weeks is not fair either.
Even though there seem to be posters on here who do not agree with the Y.E.S. rules, the rules are the rules. Children can register based on AGE and AVAILABILITY. So, register early and don't lie. Seems like a no-brainer to me.
Now, if we could just convince them to do classes in April when we hope to take our next WDW vacation....