i bought the evil queen eye shadow. my first mac product(our store opened about a yr ago). i love it since it's a bronzy type it's pretty neutral with my brown hair and eyes.
on the down side it tends to wear off in a line in my eyelid crease. not much difference between that and any other department store shadow i find.
A little OT, but have you tried an eye shadow base/primer? Too Faced has a great one. I believe it's called Shadow Assurance.