I haven't read through the entire thread...I assume it is mostly unconditional praise of DCL and most saying you will never be bored.
However, I did find that there were times when there is little or nothing going on. In the evening, if you decide not to go see the show, you'll find that they really do not schedule anything (with the exception of maybe a movie in the Buena Vista theater and I guess on Funnelvision) during the shows. No character greets will be scheduled, nothing in the family lounges, etc. It's clear they want everyone at the show since they don't give you many alternatives.
If you scroll back to post #34 on page 3 to the most recent posts - you'll see that there isn't unconditional praise for DCL. Fortunately for me - the production shows and movies are the things I like best about sailing on a Disney ship. However, as one who doesn't sail with minor children, I think their adult activities during port days have been lacking. Not everyone leaves the ship in port - especially in Nassau.