Same day cancellations is the whole point of the fee. Just because you think you found a loophole doesn't mean the entire system should be eliminated.
Did not say the entire system. A fee for a no show is very appropriate. And I did not "find" this loophole. It is being discussed in this thread, on other threads on these boards, and elsewhere.
For the record, in my 25 years of Disney travel and 50 or so trips, I have never ever (even once) made an ADR I did not intend to keep. Never had two or more on the same day in a different park, never used a "dining strategy"
Prior to the fee I have cancelled same day on occasion. Usually in person at my hotel or in guest services. These cancellations were met with glee by the cast members who at times would hold my cancel until they had a guest wanted it. Helped them make some magic. I have never been a no show. Ever.
since the fee, we make less ADRs to allow for being spontaneous. Twice we kept our ADR and only had drinks and an appetizer because we were just not hungry and were not going to pay $20 for nothing. A drink is always fun.
yes - now on those very rare occasions when we do not want to keep our ADR we will reschedule to another day and then maybe cancel that.
Since those in the know will be doing the same, maybe it is indeed time to adjust the fee policy to cover no shows and allow people on vacation to modify their plans - especially since the app does not allow double bookings. Unless you have a dining strategy that works around this. Way too much work for a vacation.