Hi Deb
We went on the
Disney Cruise with my brother's family 4 years ago. Our daughter is deaf and was 10-years-old at the time.
We were very unhappy with Disney's accommodations for deaf children on the cruise to the point where I filed a complaint with the Department of Justice. I am not confrontational and we are big Disney fans.
First of all, we had to switch our sailing dates because Disney would only provide an interpreter on limited, predetermined cruises. We were able to do this without too much difficulty. This was a minor inconvenience for us.
Disney implied that there would be interpreters or staff that could communicate in American Sign Language working in our daughter's children's club. I requested it in writing, well in advance, as many of you know is required by the ADA law. The children's programming was a big draw for us. Our daughter is very social and is the kind of kid that would have loved to be involved in all the activities. Unfortunately her participation was very much limited. They offered to move her to the teen group because one of the staff there knew a little bit of sign, but I wasn't comfortable with my then 10-year-old socializing with teens. The children's program staff were wonderful, but they they didn't know how to communicate with her.
The shows and the safety drill were interpreted and the interpreter was of the highest caliber.
At the time, Disney negotiated a contract each year with an interpreting services company, but did not include interpreting the children's activities in that contract. This is when the sailing dates were also decided on. They would not provide interpreters on cruises other than those dates.
Had I known in advance that there would be limited accessiblity for my daughter to the children's program, we could have prepared our daughter, adjusted our expectations or chosen not to go on the cruise, but because I was misled we didn't have an opportunity to do so.
I called guest services upon our return and got a blanket apology and assurances that they would be changing nothing. We were very disappointed.
We have used Disney's interpreter services at Disney World in Orlando and have been very satisfied and impressed, but know that it took a lawsuit for Disney to provide those services.
This was our experience. Different families with different children may have better experiences. Some deaf children have decent enough oral skills and would not need an interpreter; some older deaf children can be included through writing. In my opinion Disney should have interpreted the club activities, and certainly should not have told me they would be interpreted if they were not.
I sure hope that things have improved since then.
Tina