Here's my awards, now that I've stayed at all 3........
Best overall value
gold MOWC
silver Dolphin
bronze Gaylord
Best room
gold Gaylord Emerald Bay
silver MOWC
bronze Dolphin
Best common areas
runaway gold Gaylord atrium
silver MOWC
Bronze Dolphin
Best pool:
gold MOWC
silver Dolphin/Swan
very distant bronze Gaylord
Best choice of eateries:
gold Dolphin/Swan/Boardwalk
silver MOWC
Bronze Gaylord
Best Location
gold Dolphin
silver / bronze other 2 about equal
Friendliest, most helpful staff:
gold Gaylord
silver / bronze other 2 equal
Best overall value
gold MOWC
silver Dolphin
bronze Gaylord
Best room
gold Gaylord Emerald Bay
silver MOWC
bronze Dolphin
Best common areas
runaway gold Gaylord atrium
silver MOWC
Bronze Dolphin
Best pool:
gold MOWC
silver Dolphin/Swan
very distant bronze Gaylord
Best choice of eateries:
gold Dolphin/Swan/Boardwalk
silver MOWC
Bronze Gaylord
Best Location
gold Dolphin
silver / bronze other 2 about equal
Friendliest, most helpful staff:
gold Gaylord
silver / bronze other 2 equal