Not to add further complications to this - since the OP has mentioned that the daughter is now okay with the situation - looking at the first post, it appears that they are going during Value Season (judging by the ticker in the sig line)
If they are already staying at CSR, for only $25-35 more per night, another option would be the Family Suites at ASMu.
There are, of course, benefits and drawbacks to this.
Drawbacks:
- Food court quality - at CSR you get the Pepper Market - rated highly - the food court at ASMu is okay - but not as good (judging by reviews)
- No TS restaurant at the All-Stars - although if most of your TS dining is in the parks or other resorts, this isn't a major issue
- The pool area is definitely nicer and more interesting in terms of theming at CSR - but unless the kids are really concerned about having a waterslide, the pools at ASMu are fairly large and still good for a swim
- General appearance of the resort - CSR, being a moderate, will simply look more upscale than ASMu - definitely in terms of the grounds, even if it is still an "outside" room access like the All-Stars.
Benefits:
- The Family Suite will give you TWO bathrooms - which may be ideal with kids of the age you mention
- Overall space - you will have about 314 sq. ft. at CSR - the Family Suite is 520 sq. ft.
- You will get a kitchenette with fridge, coffee maker and microwave - although you get the fridge and coffee maker at CSR, the microwave is a nice addition and allows for quick and inexpensive breakfasts in the room - possibly allowing for a quick departure in the mornings to get to the parks.
- Each child can have their own bed - leave the couch as is, and simply open up the chair and ottoman as beds. With their support system, there are no metal bars and are considered very comfortable for kids - no worse than an airbed, and better than cots.
- TWO televisions - one in the family room area with pull-out beds and one in the separate bedroom - TV's might not be an issue, but it's good to mention anyway
- The separate bedroom for the adults - gives the two of you a little privacy and the bed in there is a QUEEN as opposed to the double at CSR.
I'm sure that there might be other benefits and/or drawbacks specific to your family that I can't think of - but these are the basics that would likely apply in general.
We haven't personally stayed at the Family Suite yet - this year will be our first time - but looking at all the pics and reviews, we knew we wanted to if we ever got the chance.
We were also tempted to book CSR at one point - we haven't stayed there before either - and we liked the pics and reviews of that resort too - but for our family (Me, wife, son (8) and daughter (4)) - the extra space and privacy beat out the theming and pools. Most of our dining will be in-park too - so the restaurants weren't an issue either. It cost more than a mod - but that was something we were willing to do.
As an FYI, there have been some other threads of people asking whether the Family Suites were still available for this summer/fall value season during Free Dining. While the first week of Free Dining doesn't seem to have any Family Suites available - judging by your ticker, it looks like you will be there for the second last (or so) week, and when I checked a couple of days ago for the other thread, Family Suites came up as an option.
So, if you are booked for Free Dining, and would consider the Family Suite, you might be able to do so.
As I mentioned, I realize your daughter has had a change of heart - but I thought I would mention this in case it was something that sounded appealing.
Have a great trip!