My DD suggested I book CM for our first DIsney meal when we all went for my DGD first trip. My 4 YO Tinkerbell was totally enchanted. I don't rememebt the food that night, but I do remember every minute of our famiy enjoying the characters with her, and with us as well. WE have been back a few times since, and again, I remember eating but the interactions with the CM's and the characters stand out more for me.
This August we are taking two little girls with us on their first trip, and DD once again asked for CM as the first meal for them. I think she is right, and i really do hope that we remember those precious moments when they get to meet their "friends" for the first time.
For me, there are some things that Disney does so well, and we have been Blessed that during every trip we have taken, we have experienced classic Disney charm in the character meals. I know that a lot of people really do not like CM, but we have never been disappointed there, whereas our Tusker House breakfast was a let down. The food was good (funny I seldom remember the food at character meals) but the character interaction was sporatic at best, and IMO rushed when they finally got around to us. So I guess you have to see for yourself.