It's only a good deal for those who spend mucho bucks on eating a lot of food.
and for those who don't like to tip much. they should have included EITHER the appetizer or the dessert. but they should have definitely kept the 18% tip. we could have lived without the app. or des. definitly a lot of food and would have been willing to pay OOP to split an appetizer, but for those of us who are used to tipping well (20%) the lousy one dollar drop put us out of the market. even if they included the tip, we would still buy into it.
for those who say service was bad because the tip was included... I never found that to be the case, we usually tipped extra, but they did not know that until the meal experience was over.