Ok so I know this is a DCL forum but I figured somebody has to have sailed with Carnival before. I want to surprise my DBF for our anniversary next year (it'll be our 5th) and I was thinking of a cruise. I found a 6 day one, on the Carnival Freedom, that goes to Key West, Jamaica, and Grand Cayman that's less than $500/person! Good deal! But I've never sailed with Carnival and I've heard some mixed things. I'm not new to cruising; I've sailed with NCL and RCCL before. A lot of people hate NCL but I'm not picky which leads me to think I would like Carnival. But I'm just curious on other people's feedback...